Menu

They aren't sandwiches. They aren't subs.

Authentic.
Pennsylvania.
Hoagies.

Authentic.
Philly.
Cheesesteaks.

Authentic.
Pennsylvania.
Dutch.

Now opening in Chilly Water!

We are very excited to announce that we are opening our second location right inside of Chilly Water Brewing Company (21+) in the Fletcher Place neighborhood!

Chilly Water

Hoagies in the news

Tasting Indy
Tasting Indy
FOX59 - Sherman
FOX59 - Sherman
Butler Blue
Butler Blue
Sean in the City
Sean in the City
Eat Here Indy
Eat Here Indy
WISH TV
WISH TV

Who we are

*Friday & Saturday closing hours are subject to change.

Thank you so much for all your business and support through the years! We wouldn't be here with out you!
We have been serving up PA style Hoagies & Cheesesteaks along with PA Dutch specialties in Indy since 2015. Using Liscio's Rolls from South Jersey, Dietz & Watson cold cuts, house sauces, Seltzers Lebanon Bologna, & slicing our Delmonico Ribeyes in house you will surely get a southeast PA experience right here in the Butler Tarkington Neighborhood!

HOLIDAY FUNDRAISER!
Canned Food Drive for Saint Vincent De Paul Food Pantry Dec. 1st - Dec. 31st
Santa is Coming! Kids of all ages may bring a non perishable item for a photo with Santa! - Dec. 19th 12-3p

Gift Card Deal!
Get a $25 Gift Card for $20 - Nov. 26th & 27th

Holiday Hours:
Thanksgiving - Closed
Black Friday - 1p-8p
Christmas Eve - 11a-4p
Christmas - Closed
NYE - 11a-7p
NYD - Closed

Recent photos