Menu

They aren't sandwiches. They aren't subs.

Authentic.
Pennsylvania.
Hoagies.

Authentic.
Philly.
Cheesesteaks.

Authentic.
Pennsylvania.
Dutch.

Virtual gift cards now available!

Order Now!

We are very excited to announce that we are now offering virtual gift cards for sale that can be emailed directly to your friends and family (or maybe even yourself) this holiday season! Available in any denomination!

Order Now!

Hoagies in the news

Tasting Indy
Tasting Indy
Butler Blue
Butler Blue
Sean in the City
Sean in the City
Eat Here Indy
Eat Here Indy

Who we are

From the Owner:
We are a small business with one location, sourcing most of our ingredients in from S. Jersey, Philly & the PA Dutch regions. We use high quality beef and cold cuts for our sandwiches, slice veggies in house and have family own recipes for sides and sauces. Please do not compare us to other sandwich shops or chains. Our prices only reflect the love and passion we have for bringing a taste of my home, here to Indy.
Thank you so much for all your business and support through the years! We wouldn't be here with out you. :)

More details:
We have been serving up PA style Hoagies & Cheesesteaks along with PA Dutch specialties in Indy since 2015. Using Liscio's Rolls from South Jersey, Dietz & Watson cold cuts, house sauces, Seltzers Lebanon Bologna, & shaved ribeye, you will surely get a southeast PA experience right here in the Butler Tarkington Neighborhood. This is the only Eagles Nest in the Midwest so all you Philadelphia Eagles fans have a home to cheer on your favorite team!

CATERING always available!
Hosting a Graduation, Birthday, Fundraiser, Sports Party, Office Luncheon? Call Us for your CATERING NEEDS!

We now have Tuesday Night Trivia!
Every Tuesday starting Feb. 6th. 7p-9p
All Ages - Up to 6 per team
Gift Card Prizes for 1st & 2nd Place teams